"We went here per the recommendation of our tour guide, who also happened to be the owner. I really wanted to like the place, but the food was a disappointment. I had the baked potato soup, which had little flavor and was not creamy. Also had the salmon spread with pita chips. Pita chips were puffy, not crisp and the salmon spread tasted more like cream cheese than salmon spread. The waffle dessert just completed the trifecta of letdown. Needless to say, I’d explore other options in Sitka before coming back here again."

"Had the bagel with locally caught spread and it was good - soft bagel and the spreas was subtle. The hot choloate was just ok (tasted like powdered chocolate drink). My friends were disappointed with the coffee too. No bathroom."

"This place is absolute wonderful for food and excursions. You will not be disappointed. We paid more in Juneau but happier with everything in Sitka. Great customer service that is hard to find this day and time!!! We were looking for something to do in Sitka while on a cruise and reached out to bumble excursions. I called and had to leave a message and Sara actually called back. We talked for literally an hour about EVERYTHING. She IS Wonderful!! Brett and Cole did a fabulous job taking us on a land and water excursion of Sitka. Love to go back because of This wonderful company. Sara is fantastic!! Can’t say enough how wonderful misfit cafe and bumble excursions were!"

"Visited Misfit Island cafe on July 17 2025. All staff were super helpful and very friendly. Coffee was great but the gluten free pastry was outstanding, and the cookie with chocolate chip and alaskan sea salt was sublime! Highly recommended."

"I really wanted to love this space. We visited for a coffee pick-me-up while walking around in town. It's a nice walk to this area with a ton of shops, historic elements, and food options. We just ordered coffee which tasted so burnt, the cream and sugar couldn't help it much. The staff seemed more focused on messing around with each other and joking than focusing on work. It was busy when we were there, but waiting almost 20 minutes for 2 coffees is a bit much. I don't know if they needed more staff or just more focused staff. I would recommend trying somewhere else local."