"This was my first experience at Edgar’s in Homewood. Kris was so helpful and accommodating. I had made an online order but got the date wrong. She went ahead and filled my order with a smile. I plan to go back when I have more time!"

"On Wednesday, August 27th, my husband and daughter bought a chocolate cheesecake from Edgars in Homewood for my birthday. Sadly, we had to throw it away—it tasted absolutely awful, like sour milk. When my husband told me he had paid $45 for it, I almost fainted! He paid for the location instead of flavor or quality. Highly disappointed. This wasn’t my first disappointing experience there. I’ve been with friends to have coffee, and instead of serving it in ceramic cups like any proper coffee shop, they serve it in cardboard cups. Even so, we sat down to chat and enjoy our coffee, but because the place was about to close, we were asked to leave. Between the unfriendly service, poor presentation, and overpriced food, I can honestly say this place is highly disappointing."

"I got the strawberry flavor rose ombré cake in purple for my daughter 20th birthday and it was gorgeous as well as delicious 🤤. Cake was moist and just right in all the ways of not being too sweet or dry ."

"This was one of the most frustrating dining experiences I’ve ever had. I attempted to order a breakfast sandwich and was told that only ciabatta bread was available. After payment was taken, I was then informed that ciabatta bread was actually the only thing they were out of.... which should have been communicated before checkout. When I asked to order croissants, the cashier was unaware that croissants were even offered/sold. When we tried to order a latte, the cashier didn't even know how to use the espresso machine.... I would compare the dining experience to that of a hospital cafeteria. The food took an excessive amount of time to be prepared, the staff was not friendly or helpful, and the food itself was very poor in quality. Come for the baked goods and avoid everything else."

"Edgar's is THE place to get fresh baked goods, sweets, or a great lunch. This location didn't disappoint (every location is great). Staff is incredible, food portions are great, and taste is phenomenal. Must have if you are in the neighborhood and worth the trip if you aren't. We will definitely be back for more."