"This was our first time hearing about this place and not only was the atmosphere very nice, antique in a way, but I felt like we were in an episode of Cheers because it was just so warming and welcoming! The waitress was kind ! Food was great! The burger was very juicy!!! The mushrooms cooked to perfection! The fries tasted homemade too!!! My daughter loved their chicken tenders too! All in all can't wait to try them again in the future!"

"My Aunt had talked up Butch Cassidy's and said they had the best taco salad ever but she only ever ordered that. So for my first time eating here, we decided to try the tues special hamburger steak as a to-go order with a side of fried green tomatoes. The good: The green tomatoes are a little thin but seasoned and tasty. The cornbread is the star. I don't normally eat my whole cornbread but I inhaled this one and wished for more. The not so good: The hamburger steak was dry and not very flavorful, which would've been ok if the gravy made up for it. I can't tell if the gravy was good though, because there wasn't enough there to get a decent taste. The greens were so unbearably salty that I couldn't eat it. I can handle eating food that is a bit too salty but these greens were basically a veggie flavored salt lick. My aunts order looked and tasted the same. It could be that they were having an off night or running out of gravy for the special, but if so, I would've rather been informed about that so I could choose something else. If this is their usual portion of gravy, I will choose somewhere else. I'm fairly sure the greens were a one off or no one would order them. I'm going to give them another try and I'm sure I will be able to ammend my review to a better score."

"Great burgers 🍔. Staff was very friendly. Food came out really quick, even the server was surprised at the speed of the order. Everything we ordered came out piping hot and tasty. We ordered the fried green tomatoes and the order was cooked perfectly. I had the Butch burger medium and I got it medium, nice job. Very tasty burger with great fries. The wife ordered the prairie burger and she said the fried tomato on top made the burger really good. Glad we found this place, we will return."

"Nice cafe. Specialize in burgers but plenty of other options. The have a daily special for $12. On Monday, it is red beans, rice, sausage. Very nice. Nice waitress. Probably 20 tables plus a bar. They seat you quickly and get your beverage quickly but once the food order it taken, it can take a while (and they tell you so.) very little parking, so may need to find street parking. Glad I went and would go again."

"I purchased the Butch Burger and onion rings. The burger was good, but a little dry. The onion rings were fantastic. The atmosphere was very nice and relaxing and it was fun watching the locals mingle with each other. If I’m back in town, I will definitely visit again."