"This shop is special. The marshmallow sweets taste delicious, the team is fun and kind, and the owners care about their community in many ways. We requested custom mallow-pops and the team responded same day. They were able to make 45 individually wrapped custom marshmallow pops within 2ish days! Definitely a fun alternative for a classroom birthday. This place is a must visit if you have a sweet tooth and want to support local. 10/10 recommend."

"I still can’t believe my luck, just 20 minutes from my home is the most incredible little marshmallow shop! From the moment you walk in, you’re surrounded by pure joy and deliciousness! The shakes that are out of this world (the frozen hot chocolate is my absolute favorite), gooey s’mores toasted right in front of you, and shelves full of fresh, creative treats that keep me and my family coming back again and again. What makes Toasted Mallow truly unforgettable, though, is the people. The kind of personalized customer service that makes you feel like family. If you haven’t treated yourself here yet, do yourself a favor and get there fast. Trust me, these are the kinds of sweet memories you’ll want to come back for."

"Sweet Dreams & Even Sweeter Service at The Toasted Mallow! 🍭✨ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ From the moment we walked into The Toasted Mallow at 1034 North Gilbert Road, we were greeted with the warmest smile from Brooklyn—who made our very first visit feel like a sweet adventure! Her friendliness, energy, and knowledge of the menu made it easy to pick the perfect treat. We went with the Cotton Candy Fantasy Milkshake, and let me tell you… it was magical! Like dessert heaven in a cup. We also grabbed four cupcakes, and each one was better than the last. Everything was fresh, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. The vibe of this place is so fun, colorful, and welcoming—it’s a whole experience, not just a dessert stop. From the unique treats to the great service, The Toasted Mallow is a must-visit. I’m already planning my next trip and can’t wait to tell friends and family about this gem. If you haven’t been yet—this is your sign!"

"Toasted Marshmallow: A Sweet Little Adventure If Willy Wonka opened an ice cream shop, it might look a lot like Toasted Marshmallow. This place is a sugar-coated dream come true—with a twist! I ordered one of their famous milkshakes expecting the usual whipped cream on top, but nope—a whole scoop of marshmallow sits there like a sugary crown. It’s gooey and totally genius. The vibe inside is cozy and playful, like summer camp meets dessert heaven. They’ve even thought about the sticky situation, each table has wet naps ready to go. Sounds small, but after diving into a marshmallow-topped masterpiece, you’ll be grateful. Flavors are bold, creative, and made with care. Whether you’re into classics with a twist or full-on flavor explosions (looking at you, "Goofy Goober"), there’s something for everyone here. You can tell the folks behind the counter love what they do, smiles all around, and not just from the sugar rush. Come hungry, leave sticky, and definitely plan to come back."

"Very cute and sweet treats! Staff were very nice. Just a heads-up for those who care: the guy at the counter did say that the cupcakes were a box mix but everything else is handmade."