"We tried the soft serve, the build-a-pint and the cookies as well. Service was great, and the ice cream was fantastic. They only had two flavors of ice cream and I went for the cereal milk ice cream one and completely loved it. I also paired it with a chocolate chip cookie and it went well. The flavor reminded me a bit of vanilla with a hint of salt caramel ice cream for some reason. Would definitely be back if I'm ever in the area again."

"Went for dessert and left happy, the cookies and soft serve are the stars, sweet, nostalgic, and fun, the staff was quick and the shop has that energetic Melrose feel. This place is great for a late-night treat just be patient and ready for a line, would happily come back as Im a dessert lover LOL"

"Love all their unique flavors!! Parking is limited, inside gets packed so expect to wait. There is a pretty large inside seating area and a unisex restroom for customers only."

"Milk Bar.. it was more like Potato Chips. Not sure if we went on an off day but it was .. salty. Weird tasting. 🥴. I’ll be honest, We were expecting like super milky creamy Sweet smooth soft serve.. 🍦! This was our first time there and they offered a sample. We tried it and my son had an immediate reaction on his face and mouthed the word ‘salty?’ But the Cashier girl was just starting at us, eye pressured and sure.. I didn’t want to be rude.. at that time they were the only ice cream shop open that late .. we were the only customers. Do we leave? Do we stay? Maybe it was just that flavor that tasted salty.. so we ordered 2 cups.. and nope, the 2 flavors we got were salty. We politely tried our best to finish it, couldn’t down it all. Highly unlikely we will ever go back. If you go, ask for a sample 1st and eat the sample outside. Staff was great 👍🏼. Super friendly, store was clean, parking is good. We also got a cookie and that was good."

"Love getting to see this place and picking out all the various yummy goodies they have to offer. Personal fave is getting a cereal milk shake or a birthday cake cookie! Take home a tin so you can keep get a keepsake or reminding you to fill it back up. lol"