
About The Bagel Mill
Sleek daytime destination for house-made bagels & sandwiches, plus coffee, tea & pastries.
What People Are Saying
from Google"The workers here seem really sweet and funny 🥰 and they’re happy to help describe and suggest their products to help you decide, which is hard to come by at coffee shops. Just tried their new fall drink 🍂, the Pecan Praline ice latte, made from one of their many housemade syrups and has the warmth in its flavor of a pecan pie. And the chocolate chip cookie is lightly salted, with the perfect ratio of sweet and salty. The space is so nice and spacious yet cozy, with beautiful plants that add to the charm. Sitting at the window bar table, I have such a beautiful view of the little shops and people enjoying the sunny day. I’ve only had good experiences coming here 🤎"
"This was my first time coming here and oh my gosh 10/10!!! This has to be the best bagel shop that has the traditional open face lox and cream cheese special!! The sliced salmon was super fresh, cream cheese was delicious!! The onions were thinly sliced, and the capers were just amazing!! I was really shook!! My favorite place is in New York City, but this comes right behind! I seriously recommend this place!! The staff here is wonderful, super friendly!!! This is my new spot!!!"
"The bagels are amazing! Not just OK, amazing. The seasonal cream cheeses are also a must try. Always changing, always good. I too love their rugelach, though I bummed they no longer sell them as a multi pack. They were a sweet little gift. ;)"
"First time I have ever tried these bagels and I found not one but three hair in my bagel!!! I didn’t want to eat it because I had no idea was else the bagel had inside 🤢"
"Oh my, the bagels here are truly divine! This was the perfect breakfast stop on our roadtrip to Sonoma, and the staff was super friendly too. I had the Cream Cheese and Greens bagel sandwich and it was perfect - fresh, delicious, and satisfying. You really can't go wrong with any of their options, and they have so many different kinds of bagels to choose from that are baked fresh in house! You've got to go!"
Hours
Nearby Coffee Shops in Petaluma