"**A Hidden Gem on Shelter Island!** ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Portside Coffee and Gelato is exactly what you want in a neighborhood coffee spot - a true little gem that delivers on all fronts. This cozy hole-in-the-wall may be small, but it packs a big punch with everything you need for the perfect coffee experience. The service here is outstanding - clean, fast, and genuinely friendly. I love that you can even call ahead, which is such a thoughtful touch for busy mornings. The staff clearly cares about getting you in and out efficiently without sacrificing quality. Don't let the compact size fool you - they've got a fantastic menu with an impressive variety of both hot and cold drinks, plus food options to satisfy any craving. The gelato selection is a delicious bonus that sets them apart from your typical coffee shop. The colorful outdoor seating adds such a cheerful vibe to the whole experience. It's the perfect spot to enjoy your drink and soak up some San Diego sunshine. Sometimes you don't need bells and whistles - just great coffee, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere. Portside delivers exactly that. Highly recommend this Shelter Island treasure!"

"Very nice gelato, good flavor, big portions. Staff is very nice and friendly. Chai latte is amazing. These options are also safe for celiacs and people with gluten allergy, just make sure to specify it in advance."

"In the last 5 days we visited numerous coffee establishments and this one by far exceeds them. The coffee, pastries and the Cali breakfast burrito has me returning tomorrow before we head back to Florida. The service is fast and on point!!!!"

"Really cute place with a nice location and sitting outside as well as the coffee! Came here to meet some friends and everyone seemed to really enjoy the coffee there. I tried to keep it healthy so got a cold brew with sugar-free vanilla syrup and a splash of half and half. I guess the vanilla syrup was quite expensive because it was 90 cents for a pump of syrup which felt quite extra! Definitely good portion size though and the coffee was nice! The friends I went with were visiting and one of them is actually quite a coffee connoisseur, and he said that this coffee was actually very nice and he had even come here the previous day!"

"Gelato prices are very reasonable and even the small size is quite big. $5/$6/$7 for small/medium/large. I can highly recommend the Mud Pie flavor (espresso based)."