"Fantastic bagels. Probably one of the best in the state. Their everything bagel with cream cheese is a perfect go-to option. The service is nice and generally quick, but you'll likely wait 5-10 minutes for anything that needs preparation. You also wait in line for 15 minutes to get bagels. Overall, it's worth it, you just need to be ready to stand for a bit. Consider ordering ahead and picking up."

"Great sourdough bagels— nice crisp texture on the outside, with a soft dense chewy inside. My favorite is the rosemary olive oil but also enjoyed their togarashi spice, lava salt, and everything bagels. They are very innovative with their bagel flavors and make very solid sandwiches. Waited about 10-15 minutes for two breakfast sandwiches on a weekday. They also have other baked goods and desserts that look incredibly delicious as well. Sitting inside is very comfortable for studying/working while enjoying a bagel and a coffee."

"BEST bagels around hands down… PLUS they are great for gluten sensitivity. Fresh, quality ingredients with charming atmosphere. Get there early-they often sell out! Lucky to have them in the area."

"Awesome spot. Growing family regulars here. Recommended for any out of town visitors - if you can find a parking spot and arrive before their bagels are sold out! Bagels aside though, great coffee, pastries and positive vibes all around. Even the love they poured into the original building. We're all about Blue House Bagels!"

"I've been here several times now, and everything is absolutely fantastic. The French Toast bagels were incredible, and even something simple like a chocolate chip cookie was extraordinary. Plus it's a great hangout spot as well with the antique beams and very nice old fireplace. Highly recommend!"