"RESTAURANT REVIEW Nica's Market New Haven Opened in 2002, Nica's Market is an Italian Deli located on Orange Street in New Haven CT. Nica's offers a wide variety of delicious sandwiches, salads, panini's and more. There are a wide variety of fresh made "hot foods" to satisfy local residents and workers appetites. The prices are slightly above the local average but the food is top notch.....most of the time. The one downside is the customer service, despite touting about it on their website. After visiting many times in a short period I was never met with the "outstanding customer service" they boast about. The food preparers seem all over the place and don't greet you with a friendly smile. Several order specifics were ignored on every one of my visits, including missing ingredients and added ingredients that were not ordered. Out of the 12 days I ate at Mica's, my "hot" food was stone cold, despite sitting on the hot bar. This happened at all times of the day as early as 11 AM and as late as 3PM. Bottom line. The food is delicious and the selection is great. If you have the patience to deal with a few annoying mistakes and inconsistent service definitely check this deli out just based on the amazing variety of Italian foods. Contrary to the food preparers, the girls that work the coffee counter are friendly and charming and always end the experience on a high."

"I expected a regular sandwhich from the deli counter but I couldn't even beleive the Cowgirl Deli sandwhich. It was packed with amazing ingredients that really harmonized all the ingredients. The fact that they stacked up the deli meats and just dropped a few drops of vinegar, olive oil and dressings made this sandwhich amazing. I couldn't eat it all at once. The second half is going to be for dinner."

"Nica's Marketplace in New Haven offers a delightful experience. We tried the portobello mushroom panini and chicken pennette, both of which were delicious. The prices are more affordable compared to other places, and there are many food options to choose from. The gelato ice creams were exceptional. I look forward to visiting again."

"Nica's is a charming neighborhood deli that offers a variety of mouthwatering options, from hearty sandwiches and paninis to fresh salads and homemade soups. It's been a favorite local spot for years. I recommend their chicken cutlet sandwich, especially when paired with fresh mozzarella and roasted red peppers on focaccia. The outdoor seating area is perfect for enjoying your meal on a sunny day.​ One of my favorite hidden gem's in the east rock neighborhood."

"Ordered party Trays for Christmas Eve! I ordered 1 Small Antipasto tray, and 1 small Calamari tray… we ordered one week in advance. When we arrived on December 31st 11:30am, they could not find the order! We waited in the pick up line for 1 hour! Then the owner came out to say we should have picked it up the day before. So frustrating and low class!!! Any way finally after losing our parking spot They called us and said they redid our order and it was ready Later I realized She charged my card, which they had for $179.00. Whattttt???? Yes $179.00. That’s a rip off!!!! We will never go to this market ever again!!! Too bad. They lost a good customer for their poor customer service and greed!…. also the food was not even fresh !!!!!! Charlie Farricielli and Family."