"San Matteo was very accommodating, clean, and the drinks and apps were amazing! The service started off great we were greeted at the front and taken to the dining area which I did not expect to be so large. It was beautifully decorated and was a great vibe. Our waiter promptly brought our drinks. The lemonade is freshly made and delicious. My friends got drinks that they raved about. At some point I server stopped coming by as much. We placed an order for apps and they came out in a fairly timely manner. We loved the fritto misto. Our entrees took a little while to come out which is fine but our server never came by to check in or to just let us know it was on the way, which was a little off putting. We ordered the squid ink pasta, lemon and spinach ravioli dish, manicotti dish, and the parpadelle funghi dish. One of us loved our dish and that was the lemon spinach ravioli. The others felt like there was a lack of flavor and the seafood in my squid ink seemed over cooked. One of my friends asked if she could change the sauce in her squid ink pasta and the restaurant happily accommodated, so that was very nice. I would come back for the appetizers. We got the fritto misto which was amazing and the arancini dish which I loved. I would say give it a try if you’re interested."

"Only came here late for wine , cappuccino & dessert — but given that I searched the reviews for recommendations and wasn’t finding anything, wanted to leave a review: I had a chocolate tooth - and the chocolate lava cake was hands down the best I’ve ever had - I’ve had far too many in my life that were let downs, but nope, I am SO glad I got it. The cake itself melted in my mouth and was overflowing with a delicious ganache filling - and was the perfect level of sweetness. It was on the smaller side and came with a small scoop of gelato. Our group also got the crostata di mele — definitely a unique variation of this based on my expectation from google images. It is fried and a is croissant like pastry with a fresh apple filling interspersed within it — you can see the crispy croissant texture in my pictures — and it had a fried oily flavor to it that I was not expecting, and quite honestly took away from the flavor from the apples some. My partner really enjoyed it, though. I just wasn’t expecting the heavy fried flavor — not for me, so wanted to make others aware. My espresso drink (cappuccino) was great and they were able to make it with skim milk. Our wait staff didn’t realize we weren’t eating a late dinner at first and had brought out bread btw, as well as a mixture of olive oil, vinegar and spices. I ended up eating it anyway and it was delicious. Bread was warm and so soft and fresh. Service was great - waitress was friendly and attentive. The back patio / greenhouse like room is very big, echoey and loud, just FYI. If you’re looking for a more quiet, intimate or romantic place for a date, for example, would be more apt to recommend the main/front dining room or the bar in that main/front dining room. I def look forward to coming back here for dinner soon!!"

"Three of us dropped in late on a Monday, not many patrons. 10/10. Very solid wine recommendations and the food was stellar. Octopus was perfect. Meatballs/polenta were delicious. The main plates,new york, butternut carbonara, etc. were each really tasty. Our waitress doubled as the bartender (caro I think was her name), which led to some nice limoncello. One of the best italian spots in the city and no one knows about it!"

"As someone who truly loves Italian food, I stumbled upon this restaurant while exploring the neighborhood and decided to stop in. From the moment I walked through the door, I felt welcomed. The staff was incredibly friendly and attentive, answering all my questions about the menu and offering excellent recommendations. The food was fantastic — every dish I tried was flavorful, fresh, and beautifully prepared. The drinks were equally impressive, with a great selection that complemented the meals perfectly. The manager also stopped by to check on me and made the experience even more personal and enjoyable. Overall, it was a delightful dining experience. I can’t wait to come back and try more of their menu. Highly recommended for anyone who loves authentic Italian cuisine!"

"I stopped by this restaurant with two coworkers after a long, exhausting day, and it became the highlight of our week... The restaurant was completely packed, and we arrived without a reservation... we were honestly prepared to leave. But the manager greeted us warmly, assured us he would take care of us, and within minutes he found us a great table. Even with the place buzzing and every seat taken, he remained incredibly attentive the entire night, checking on us often and making sure everything was perfect. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, the kind of place where you instantly feel comfortable. The entire team was extremely friendly, always smiling and making us feel welcome. I ordered the lasagna, and I can’t recommend it enough. It was unbelievably delicious, perfectly layered, comforting, rich, and easily the best lasagna I’ve had in years. If you visit, you must try it. My coworkers loved their dishes as well. Despite the full house, the service was impressive, and the manager’s kindness made the experience even more special. If you’re looking for delicious Italian food, amazing service, and a cozy place to unwind, this spot is a must. We left happy, impressed, and already planning our next visit. Five stars without hesitation! 👏👏👏"