"We love holy moley! I usually get an everything or rainbow bagel with plain cream cheese and my boyfriend likes to get the Bacon Egg and Cheese Everything bagel. The couple who owns this is also so nice and the place has a very cute bagel shop aesthetic."

"Great little bagel shop with really great food. Smoked gouda, various sausages, and good quality; but my advice would be to improve the atmosphere more in-line with Atlantic Beach ocean-inspired culture. It’s a bit “cold” inside."

"Holy Moley is right! By far the best bagels I’ve had! So soft and flavorful. I did the Giulia- stacked with delicious toppings. Will be back soon!!"

"The bagels and breakfast sandwiches are amazing! 🥰 We found a new favorite place for breakfast! Everything tastes fresh and flavorful. Such a great little shop! We will be visiting regularly and feel lucky to have this shop nearby. 👍♥️👍♥️👍♥️"

"The bagels WERE good, but that’s about it. I paid over $18 for a half dozen bagels with nothing on them or done to them and a coffee, which seems ridiculous. The coffee setup was bare bones minimal. The people were nice but this experience felt like it was missing a lot for the price I paid. I left disappointed. A little more effort in the setup/atmosphere, and more reasonable prices and this place has a lot of potential. But right now I would not got back."