"I eat here regularly and it remains my favorite spot on the Island for breakfast or lunch-- without question. It's simple food, at a reasonable price & crafted with care. Don't let the "simple" part mislead you. Romel is a fantastic chef, who takes tremendous pride in his creations-- whether its an omlette, a unique twist on a traditional sandwich or a Caesar salad with grilled chicken. Every menu option is a winner and every dine-in experience is a comfortable and enjoyable time. The best kept secret in BHI!!!"

"Absolutely loved this place! The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, and the owners are incredibly kind; it feels like you’re being welcomed by old friends. The coffee is top-notch and the food is fresh, flavorful, and made with care. A perfect spot for catching up with friends and enjoying some quiet moments with a delicious brew. Can’t wait to come back!"

"Bay Harbor Cafe has terrible customer service. A woman attacked me with accusations about why I sat down without ordering, and then she kicked me out of the place. I do not recommend this place to anyone."

"Great coffee, great breakfast & good selection. Lunch is really good & service is awesome, especially Romel very friendly & helpful. I recommend this place to everyone 👌. P.s. Thanks to Claudia from next door, she recommended your deliciousfood!"

"small cute cafe serving hispanic staples. stopped for a quick snack for kids. standard croquetas, not the best. juice was good. would return when in area to try other menu options and update stars if deserved"