What People Are Saying
from Google & Yelp"Fresh, authentic NY-style bagels done right, loaded sandwiches that hit every time, and solid coffee to start the day. Super friendly and fast service too. What a treat in our little slice of paradise on Big Pine Key. Highly recommend to anyone passing through, if you're on Big Pine, don't miss Bagel Island. Strongly recommend! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️"
"The food and service were amazing! We stopped by on our way home from Fantasy Fest, and even though it was super busy, the staff hustled to get orders out quickly. I'm definitely adding this to my list of must-visit places every time I'm down in the Keys!"
"Stopped in here for a asiago bagel breakfast sandwich. Simple but tasty. Highly recommend. Super friendly staff. Prompt service."
"I recently had the pleasure of dining at a bagels and coffee spot in Big Pine Key. Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe exceeded all of my expectations. This place offered a wide array of options for breakfast and lunch, including bagels, croissants, muffins, and eggs breakfast specials. The variety of choices on the menu was impressive, making it easy to find something to satisfy any craving. Whether you're in the mood for a savory bagel sandwich or a sweet muffin to start your day, this spot has got you covered. The quality of the food was outstanding, with each item being fresh, flavorful, and prepared with care. I particularly enjoyed the breakfast specials with eggs, which were cooked to perfection and paired wonderfully with all of the other ingredients. The atmosphere of the restaurant was warm and inviting, with a laid-back vibe that made it the perfect spot to relax and enjoy a delicious meal. The staff was friendly and attentive, adding to the overall positive experience. Overall, I highly recommend this bagels and coffee spot in Big Pine Key to anyone looking for a fantastic breakfast or lunch option. The food, atmosphere, and service all exceeded my expectations, and I will definitely be returning in the future."
"Very tasty handmade bagels!!! Best nova cream cheese and peanutbutter with jam!"
"Stopped by for breakfast/lunch on the way up from Key West. I got an egg and cheese breakfast sandwich on an onion bagel. The food was hot and fresh and the..."
