"Cute Bakery!! Delicious pastries of all sorts. European type pastry, many different cookies, cupcakes, deserts. Great variety. We bought three different types of pastries and ohhhh they were all so good. They had European names so I do not remember what they were called but flaky pastry, flavored filling and cream cheese type filling and just so good we came back the next morning as we were leaving town to buy some more. The gentleman who waited on was wonderful, very nice and good conversationalist."

"Nana Teresa’s Bake Shop is an absolute gem! The moment you walk in, you’re greeted with the cozy, welcoming charm of a small-town bakery paired with the smell of fresh-baked goodness. The selection is incredible — from cakes and cookies to pastries and specialty items, there’s something for everyone. Honestly, there were so many options that I couldn’t just pick one, and I’m glad I didn’t because everything I tried was delicious. What really stands out is not only the quality of the baked goods but also the attention to detail and care that clearly goes into everything they make. The shop itself is cute and inviting, the kind of place that makes you want to linger a little longer while you decide on your next sweet treat. If you’re in the area, this is a must-visit bakery. Whether you want a quick treat, something special to bring home, or even a gift for someone, Nana Teresa’s Bake Shop won’t disappoint. I’ll definitely be back!"

"A wonderful and convenient stop after dinner out in Fernandina! There was a huge selection of treats and everything we tried was delicious! They have boboa tea, which my teenage daughter was thrilled about and thought was great! The atmosphere is like a quaint little diner and still felt roomy enough to host a flow of patrons. Great place for a sweet stop!"

"My kids have birthdays only 3 days apart so I normally get them either mini cakes or one plain Jane bigger cake. This time I wanted to see if I could get them a double cake with each of their themes that they wanted and they did a amazing job so gorgeous. And I love red velvet got my kids to fully love red velvet and it's just amazing here. While I live here this will definitely be my go-to bake shop."

"Absolutely loved our experience at Nana Teresa's Bake Shop! We picked up the key lime pie, and it was simply delicious—perfectly creamy, tangy, and topped with just the right amount of whipped cream. The crust was buttery and crisp, adding to the overall perfection. The staff was friendly and welcoming, making our visit even more enjoyable. Can't wait to come back and try more of their baked goods. Highly recommend for anyone craving a sweet treat!"