"Stopped by Cream Republic today and loved the entire experience. Everything here is homemade, and you can taste it immediately. I had the cookie butter ice cream and it was so good creamy, rich without being heavy, and perfectly balanced. Beyond the flavor, the branding is adorable. The mermaid logo, the stickers, and the neon sign make the space feel fun and intentional without trying too hard. It’s one of those places that’s genuinely cute and good. You can tell a lot of care goes into what they’re doing, from the product to the presentation. Definitely a spot I’ll come back to, and one I’d recommend if you’re on the island."

"We were passing through and had lunch at a near by restaurant by the beach . So happy we stumbled upon this place because it was perfect! The young lady at the counter was very nice and informed us that they made all their flavors in house. I wish we had a place like this back home. If we are ever near by again I would definitely stop by . Also love supporting a local business in general. 10/10 recommend for sure! I had the white chocolate raspberry I believe and my mother had the toasted coconut. Yum!"

"Delicious ice cream and genuinely friendly service — worth the stop! We had a great experience at Cream Republic. The staff was warm and welcoming from the moment we walked in, encouraging us to try a few samples while we figured out what to order. I ended up choosing the peppermint bark from the specials list — it was rich, creamy, and full of flavor. You can tell they take pride in the quality of their ice cream. Parking was simple and close by, just off the main road to the beach, which made it an easy and convenient stop. Highly recommend if you're in the area and craving something sweet!"

"Hands down the best ice cream I’ve ever had! I’m from North Carolina and have traveled many places over the years, and I’ve had my fare share of ice cream. But each summer I spend July on the Treasure Coast with my family - and the past 4 years, this is always our go-to spot. Creamiest homemade ice cream, the best variety of flavors (with creative new ones all the time!) and great service. Wish there was a way to give it more than 5 stars ✨"

"My ice cream was sooo good. And my parents loved theirs too. We played chess while waiting. The bathroom light sensor turned off while I was in there and scared me. There were lots of ice cream flavors and toppings to choose from. The service was really good and friendly. I would totally go here again. (Review by my 8 year old son, Michael.)"