"Located off Archer a little bit south of I-75 in the Butler plaza area, this small unassuming drive thru is apparently a well known gem in Gainesville. I was told the lines can get pretty long but when we arrived around noon, it was just us. We looked at the big menu when you drive up but weren't super what we wanted to drink. We then pulled up to the order window and saw they had some additional specials and drinks. Intrigued by a couple of the options, the girl inside was very helpful letting us know what each flavor consisted of. We decided on the iced baklava with oatmilk (pistachio, white chocolate, and honey) and do not sleep on this!! Run to try this if you like those flavors!! While it was a little sweeter than I prefer, it was delicious! We also got a hot creme brûlée and it was good, mainly caramel flavored. Prices were very reasonable and service was quick and friendly. There are a lot of coffee options in this market (we went to 3 different ones in as many days) and this was by far my favorite."

"The man there is rude. I ordered a bfast sandwich and he asked what kind. I asked him what are the meat options. He said “it’s on the menu look there.” I almost drove away. I spent an entire minute trying to find it on the menu. I finally said “I see the menu that says choice of meat, but I do not see the options” and he says “other menu” a whole nother minute later I finally told him what kind I wanted. He was rude, and unhelpful. He then asked for my money and then I drove away. He ruined my morning to say the least. His attitude was uncalled for and unnecessary. He is the guy that’s usually there, I think he is the manager. Do better."

"My boyfriend and I stopped by the drive-thru 10/11/25, and the coffee was incredibly fresh and tasted amazing one of the best cups we’ve had in a while! The server was super sweet and friendly. We’ll definitely be coming back again!"

"It has a drive through! It also has outdoor seating. Smoothies and coffees available. Excellent flavor and syrup options. Plenty of smoothie choices and snacks as well."

"Bay island is one of the best coffee spots in town and is an amazing local business. Their coffee and drinks are delicious, I personally go with a refreshing fruity drink or a basic latte iced or hot and I've never had a bad drink. Decent prices for what you get, I can't recommend bay island coffee enough for tourists or people visiting, it's an experience you can't get elsewhere and is one of the benefits of Gainesville!"