"As of late the quality of their bagels have declined to sad. Even their creame cheese is sad.. the past three orders at least one and mostly 2 of a 6 pack are hard as rocks and burnt. I stopped ordering onion bagels because to burnt to eat... the plan bagels are usually spot on but who ever took over the store in Lake Mary doesn't care about quality or making good food. Shame."

"I visited The Original Brooklyn Water Bagel Co in Lake Mary today with family at 1pm (they close at 3pm). When we tried to order bagels we were told that they don't have any bagels. I looked at the menu and attempted to order a soup (which I've included a picture of the menu) and was told that they don't serve soup at this restaurant. I pointed to the board and was told that the board is wrong and it's not something they offer. When I told the employee that I guess I wasn't ordering anything she looked at me like I was crazy. I left confused. It's hard to imagine why a bagel shop runs out of bagels but the bigger issue for me was having items on your menu that are apparently incorrect. The employees at this location don't seem to care and don't apologize or offer solutions."

"We love coming here because it definitely reminds us of NY and lox bagels with all the extras of it. Very delish! Service is always friendly. We recommend this spot for whoever is looking for fresh bagels, chill environment, and great service."

"I honestly would give them five stars but you have to make your own specialty drink like the Brooklyn egg cream. No ingredient list, no portions, just an empty cup with a spoon. Next you’ll hand me a packet of cream cheese to make my own bagel. Smh"

"Frustrates me so much to how good the food is and how terrible the service is. Love the bagels, cream cheese is okay too. The coffee is good, hell they have a good menu but the counter service is pure crap. Don’t get me wrong, they are super polite, just not efficient and don’t listen very well. Ask for one flavor and get another, ask for sliced and get not sliced, excuse after excuse when it all comes down to listening and management. Best bagels around but double check your order before you leave the counter."