"We happened upon this cafe as we were exploring Tin City. Sandra’s Sweet & Savory absolutely blew me away. The dark chocolate–dipped key lime pie was honestly the best I’ve ever tasted. I can’t stop thinking about it! The blueberry scone was equally unforgettable: tender, moist, perfectly balanced, and bursting with flavor. And the best part? Sandra uses my favorite word—butter—in just about everything she bakes, and you can taste the love (and the butter!) in every bite. If you’re anywhere near this shop or see them at a farmer’s market, do yourself a favor and go. Sandra is creating pure magic in her kitchen. I can’t recommend her treats enough!"

"A Cozy Little Slice of Happiness This place is pure comfort. From the moment my son and I walked in, we were welcomed into a cozy, warm space that instantly made us feel at home. There’s something about the atmosphere.. calm, inviting, and full of heart... that makes you want to slow down and stay awhile. Sandra, the owner, is truly one of a kind. She made us feel genuinely welcomed and completely taken care of, like we weren’t just customers… we were guests. You can feel the love she puts into her shop and into everything she creates. I was seriously craving key lime pie, and it absolutely hit the spot..m smooth, bright, and perfectly balanced on a delicious graham cracker crust. My son had the chocolate mousse, which was rich, creamy, and dangerously good. Every bite felt homemade, thoughtful, and made with care. This isn’t just a bakery.. it’s a little haven. I already can’t wait to go back and try more of their baked goods and their coffee. This place is officially on our “must return” list. Thank you, Sandra, for creating such a welcoming space and for making our visit so special. We’ll definitely be back. 💚"

"We tried 4 different types of pies. Coconut cream, Mango, key lime, and banana. Hands down the best pies I’ve ever had. They were exceptional. Everything tasted super fresh. The service inside was also fantastic, and a great atmosphere. Loved it and will return 100%"

"First, I must say that the owner and the shop are great! They have many things to choose from and I wanted to try more! I tried the chocolate covered keylime pie and a Chai latte. Flavors were there! If you are someone who cares about the chocolate texture like I am, then you might not be too impressed. Unfortunately, the chocolate was a little too waxy feeling for me and didn't melt well with my bites. My chai also became very grainy towards the bottom. I had to stop drinking it. As much as I wanted to give this place a 5 star.... I had to be honest. Would I try it again? Absolutely! The caramel apple pie looks amazing!"

"If I could give more than five stars, I would. Sandra’s Pies are hands down the best pies I have ever had. The crust alone deserves its own praise. It is thick, buttery, and packed with flavor in a way most pies never come close to. It is clear that so much care and skill goes into every single pie. The key lime and peanut butter pies are absolutely incredible, though honestly I do not think you could go wrong with any flavor she offers. Every bite is genuinely memorable. We actually make the nearly 500 mile round trip just to get these pies, and every time the last slice is gone, we are immediately sad and already thinking about the next trip. On top of the amazing pies, Sandra herself is one of the kindest and most welcoming owners you will ever meet. When we realized we were going to arrive just after closing, we called and she graciously stayed open a few extra minutes so we could still pick up our pies. That level of kindness and customer care is rare and speaks volumes about her and her business. Sandra’s Pies are worth every mile of the drive and then some. Truly exceptional in every way."