"Easily one of the best coffee and bakery spots in the Orange Park and Jacksonville area. Rummies Yummies Bakery & Coffee Bar is a local favorite that deserves way more attention. The space is bright, tropical, and spotless with big windows, colorful décor, and a clean, modern layout. It’s larger than most local cafés, with two cozy lounge areas featuring leather couches for groups and plenty of tables for relaxing, studying, or working using the free WiFi. Everything is made fresh in their full commercial kitchen, and you can taste the difference. Their signature rum cakes are incredible, available by the slice, full cake, or custom order. They also serve cheesecakes, cookies, milkshakes, sundaes, and boozy desserts. The coffee bar is top-tier with a modern espresso machine, nitro cold brew, and all the milk options including oat, almond, and coconut. The owner runs the shop herself along with several other employees, which keeps the quality and service consistently excellent. It’s the perfect blend of local charm and professional polish. If you’re anywhere near Orange Park or Jacksonville, this place is a must-visit for coffee and desserts."

"While visiting Florida from out of town, my 2 year old daughter and I stopped in for a cup of coffee and a bite to eat. The two women working there were unbelievably kind and welcoming. They gave my daughter a lathe, which was such a thoughtful gesture. There was also another young girl there, who I believe was their daughter or granddaughter, and she played with my daughter the entire time. She was so polite and sweet, and it made the visit even more enjoyable. The coffee was excellent and the chocolate chip pound cake was delicious. We will definitely be back the next time we are in town."

"-Maui Wowi Rum cake was VERY impressive. We decided to sit down and try it before heading out and that led to us trying everything bc it was so good!! -Also tried the Snickers and chocolate chip cheesecakes - both were delicious. -Washed it down a Strawberry White chocolate iced latte (with coconut milk) and it was amazing!! -The restaurant is clean, well kept with a quirky, tropical vibe. Support this local business if you love a good iced latte and some down right delicious sweets!! Rum cake is the go to here-trust. -Free WiFi in this establishment with comfortable seating arrangements for group meet up’s and studying."

"The chocolate chip cookie cheesecake was soooooo good! Seriously one of the best cheesecakes I have ever had. I can't wait to come back and try more! Such a nice place & the owner Amy was so sweet."

"I've never done an online review but I just had the Snickers cheesecake and was blown away. Best cheesecake I've ever had. Looked amazing so I had to try it and it tasted better than it looked. Very nice feel in the store as well. 5 stars because 6 is not an option"