"Everything about the Over Easy Cafe is well thought out and very well done. The service was fantastic, the food was extremely good, the portion sizes were huge, and the pricing was extremely fair. The restaurant was very clean and there were plenty of options to choose from on the menu. If you’re on the islands and are looking for a banger of a restaurant to eat breakfast at, this is the one for you! 10/10, would recommend to a friend."

"Sanibel staple. My favorite spot for breakfast. Specials on weekends are great. Robbie, Mariyelli, Diego, Julian and others… great staff. Love the owners. Genuine local spot. New location is just as comfortable as the old. Nice you can sit inside at the bar, tables or outside easily. Highly reccomend the country fried steak, pigs in a blanket, their sliders and patty melt. Love being able to order breakfast for lunch or lunch for breakfast. Good coffee. Good ingredients. Hard to go wrong with any menu item ."

"Wd dined here on 9/6/25. We had a 20 minute wait. The staff is very friendly and they were working hard. I had the Mexican omelette with home fries and toast. The omelette was very tasty and the home fries were good. My wife had a Chicken Sandwich with fries. She said the sandwich was very good. The restaurant is clean and there is plenty of parking. There is a handicap ramp on the side of the shops. I rated the restaurant as a five, because you can’t give a 4.5. It is better than a four. They serve breakfast and lunch the whole they are open. There are some other shops that sell some merchandise there also."

"Arrived at 12:30 pm on a Saturday. Signage to the restaurant within the commercial center not strong. Follow your nose inside the cluster of buildings. Stairs in the front side, accessible ramp on left / south side of the complex. The dining room is airy, spacious (I'm rocking a knee scooter with a broken foot) and well appointed. We are vacationing (mid October) and came in for a late breakfast. Greeted with a clever specials poster including varieties of homemade muffins (with some crossed off because sold out). Seated quickly, the place was about half full with plenty of inside and outside seating. We opted to sit inside (I'm a heat wimp). The menu didn't disappoint (oddly not available on their website) - lots of breakfast and lunch options with inspired variations of the typical breakfast offerings. Coffee was fresh and they happily accommodated my request for 1/2 caffeine. The salmon Benedict looked amazing but big for me, I inquired about a half portion and was told "Sure but still full price". I ordered a fruit bowl option with side of fresh muffin, grilled and a side of crispy bacon (you know, for protien). Hubby ordered the Ya'll Benedict (biscuit with sausage and sausage gravy replaced hollandaise sauce with grits on the side). Both arrived quickly and didn't diasappoint. Fruit was fresh and appropriately ripe, served in a half cantaloupe bowl. The grilled strawberry mango muffin was delicious! And the 4 slices of bacon was perfectly crispy. The Benedict was tasty, flavorful sausage, delicate biscuits though eggs more hard cooked than soft boiled eggs typical of Benedict. But still delicious as evidenced by my husband's empty plate. The bill was a pleasant surprise, under $40 for 2 of us. The mix of patrons was interesting, families, couples, fit folk, older couples using canes, locals, some single diners and tourists. They had family friendly touches like workable sippy style cups which the 4 year old next to us demonstrated as well functional. Another couple sat on the porch, under the canopy with their fluffy dog. A definite "do-again" in our book!"

"We love this place. Stay at south seas but always come here and bring back. The best pancakes and muffins ever. Fresh squeezed OJ too"