"Only one person working and they were out of a lot of things (late December 2025) the gingerbread chai lattes were really good as was the key lime fudge. We waited a long time for the items since it was just the one girl."

"We stopped in during the Festival of Lights, and it was well worth it. The kids loved the ice cream, and the alcoholic coffee drink was genuinely excellent—not a gimmick, but something done right. Yes, the line was long, but that’s to be expected at a good place, and it moved quickly thanks to efficient service. Seating inside is limited, but there are plenty of spots just outside to sit and enjoy what you ordered. Prices were reasonable for the quality. Solid operation, good products, and no nonsense. We’d gladly go back."

"Cutest little specialty coffee, smoothies and much more. Quaint outside. Very nice service as well."

"One of the Best Coffee Shops in Saint Augustine I stopped by Crucial Coffee shop while walking around downtown St. Augustine, and I’m so glad I did. This place has quickly become one of my favorite coffee spots in town. The vibe is super cozy and inviting, and it’s tucked right next to the fort in a really cool historic blacksmith shop —which makes the experience even better. The coffee and lattes are seriously good and were told they use all organic beans. You can tell they care about their craft. They also have some great tea options and pastries, even sangrias and mimosas. The outdoor seating is perfect if you want to relax and enjoy the St. Augustine atmosphere. The staff was super friendly and helpful, which makes a big difference. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, I’d definitely recommend checking this place out. It’s got that mix of great coffee, friendly service, and a unique location that makes it stand out from other coffee shops in the area."

"Such a cute little place! Atmosphere is adorable and the girl working there was so friendly and fun. Husband said hot chocolate was delicious and their croissants are amazing."