"Cozy bagel shop, with everything homemade. We got several bagels and a few different cream cheese flavors. Our favorites were the scallion cream crease, and we loved the everything bagel, the Italian herbs bagel, and the cheddar jalapeño bagel. Coffee was ok, nothing to write home about, but the bagels were absolutely delicious. We loved the outdoor seating and found it very cozy and ambient. The employee was very sweet and quick to get us our food. Easy 5 stars."

"I had been eyeing this place for a couple days, I'm so glad I finally made it! I got the Dirty Duval on cheddar/jalapeño bagel and it was incredible! Perfect amount of heat. This massive sandwich was well worth it! You gotta go give one of these a try."

"Schmagel’s Bagels in St. Augustine is an absolute breakfast gem. 🥯✨ The lox and everything bagel is perfection—fresh, generously layered and bursting with flavor. The everything bagel has that ideal balance of crunch and chew, coated in seasoning that elevates every bite. The lox is silky and rich, paired beautifully with creamy schmear and fresh toppings that make it feel both indulgent and refined. The bacon, egg, and cheese bagel sandwich is just as outstanding. Perfectly cooked bacon, fluffy eggs and melty cheese come together on a warm, freshly baked bagel that holds it all without overpowering the fillings. It’s hearty, satisfying, and exactly what you want to start your morning right. Add in the welcoming atmosphere and friendly service, and Schmagel’s easily earns its spot as a must-visit breakfast stop in St. Augustine. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this is the kind of place you’ll be thinking about long after the last bite. ✨"

"This is our second time visiting St Augustine and stopping by this place. The bagels are very tasty. The reg black coffee is just ok but I usually like mine very strong so that’s just a personal preference. The place has been around for 37 years and it does tend to get busy . Inside is very small, so only about 4 people can be inside ordering; they do have a few tables outside if you want to eat there. Overall it’s a great place for breakfast or if you’re a bagel lover"

"Lovely bagel shop with a great selection of bagels, a variety of cream cheese options and delicious fresh hot coffee! Cinnamon muffins were so tempting at check out 😍 Get here early because these bagels are fresh and ready to enjoy!"