"Heavens to Besty; I’m not even a pastry eater like that but with Buttermilk Bakery, I assure you, I’ve been converted - only for them though. I absolutely love how light yet flavorful everything is - even the DONUT was light… like are you kidding me?! Pure deliciousness. There has not been one treat that I’ve tried and haven’t liked. They clearly are passionate and put love into what they do."

"I’m from Jacksonville and stumbled on Buttermilk Bakery while going down a Reddit rabbit hole looking for “the best dough in Florida” — and wow, Reddit actually came through for once! This place is small but mighty — super organized, cute outdoor seating, and the smell alone could make you spend your whole paycheck. When I showed up, it was packed, which pretty much confirmed I was in the right spot. I tried a few things (because self-control is overrated), and every single one was incredible. Flaky, buttery, perfectly baked — honestly, they could teach a masterclass in how to make carbs magical. If you’re anywhere near Winter Park, do yourself a favor and swing by. Just be ready to fall in love with everything in the display case."

"This spot has been on my list for ages and I seriously regret taking this long to try it out. Everything I ordered was nothing short of delicious. The mortadella hot honey croissant was my personal favorite! My friends and I got an assortment and the silence among us was very telling of how much we enjoyed the pastries. We will most definitely be back!"

"You know this is a popular spot when there is a line out the door! Everything is baked fresh daily. There is a wide selection of savory and sweet baked goods. My favorite today was the peach scone and bread pudding cinnamon roll. The perfect amount of sweetness, without tasting like sugar. Baked to perfection with a little crunch on the outside and soft in the middle. You can’t go wrong, everything is amazing. Coffee was good, I went with the batch brew. There is seating on the sidewalk out front and a few table available on the side porch. Parking in the street and in the back lit. I’ve noticed that several coffee shops in the area carry these baked goods."

"STOP I said to my lady friend driving. It looks good, Butterfield bakery; like the sign and sweets 😋. I'll go in and "give a look" as grandma used to say! Everything looked beautiful including the kouign-amnn. Servers were friendly and helpful describing. Put this one on your bucket list; all wonderful!"