"Wow! This is an amazing sandwich place! I had never had one before but the whole steamed bagel concept is truly amazing. Hot and delicious. Steaming the bagel makes it super tender and the meat and cheese are steamy and hot as well. The combination makes for a super flavorful mix. A new favorite place for me for sure. We tried two different sandwiches- Mr. Steamy on an asiago bagel & Mr. T on a whole wheat. Both were delicious. We got the combo and they had Zappos chips which were also delicious. Service was fast and helpful. Very clean and comfortable with some outdoor seating. Certainly 5 Star... You have to CK this place out!"

"Hands down the best sandwich I’ve ever had. SULLYS in Athens isn’t just a sandwich shop—it’s an experience. The concept is brilliant, and the food is next-level. But what really sets this place apart is the team. The owners and staff are incredibly engaged, welcoming, and genuinely care about every customer. You feel it the moment you walk in. Can’t recommend it enough."

"From the service to the food, everything was excellent! My bagel tastes like it’s made with so much love. Omg. My new favorite breakfast spot! Also, shoutout to Josh and all of the staff for greeting us on our way in and bidding us good day and a ‘please comeback soon’ on our way out. Just awesome customer service."

"Omg, this was DELICIOUS!!!!!!!! I'm excited to have this place in Athens. Service was friendly and efficient and the bagel sandwich was one of the best I've ever had. Support Sully's and keep them in Athens! Also, I had to edit this to say that Jose is awesome and made me feel welcome and right at home in the restaurant and made one heck of delicious bagel!"

"One of the best places! I love them! The atmosphere is great, the employees are always so nice and the food is absolutely amazing! I go several times a week! They’re awesome."