"Phenomenal all the way around. The food was delicious and service very good. I got the spaghetti alla nerano with salmon (made vegan). The presentation of the dish was beautiful. It is on the pricier side, but great place to visit for special treat. They offer gluten free pasta and notate the food allergens on their menu.my husband got the Petto di pollo all parmigiana which was good !"

"This was my 2nd time visiting Cafe Lily and the service was great per usual! The food was top-tier!! Sooo worth it and beautiful atmosphere! Also they have a nice wine and cocktail menu that very well pairs with all the dishes."

"It's been at least 10 years since I've been to Café Lily...shame on me. I don't remember having a better meal anywhere in downtown Decatur. The risotto was cooked perfectly, infused with perfectly seared scallop essence. The calamari presentation was wonderful, continuing to cook on a sear plate at the table. Tuna was a perfect medium/medium rare, and the crab cake, while a bit small, was one of the best I've ever had."

"Yummy food and great service. Blaze was a great server and his recommendations were delicious. He recommended adding shrimp to a popular pasta dish and it was great! I got the half portion but should have gotten the full. Yum! I tried corn chowder for the first time and it was life changing."

"We have been coming to Cafe Lily for about two years, and we have always loved it. The food is consistently fresh, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. Unfortunately, our recent anniversary dinner fell short of expectations. I usually order a half-portion of their pasta, which in the past has included 6–7 ravioli. This time, however, there were only four. I also added the grilled shrimp, which are typically prawn-sized, but instead we received just four medium shrimp for $12. Lastly, although the menu states that the first basket of bread is complimentary, none was brought to our table. I understand that prices have gone up; however, the dining expense felt hard to justify given the portion sizes we received, especially compared to our previous experiences here. I’m not sure if this dinner was just a miss with their portion sizes or if there have been some changes, but even with this experience, Cafe Lily is still one of our favorite spots for celebrating special occasions."