"Good Times Bagels has always been a unique spot with a great atmosphere, which is why this review is tough to write. I’ve been coming here for a long time, and while it used to be amazing, the quality has noticeably gone downhill. I ordered a normal bagel sandwich and was genuinely surprised by the size — apparently they now serve mini bagels. For an $8 bagel sandwich, it does taste good, but the size of the bagel itself is laughable. I keep coming back because I want this place to succeed, but I’m writing this in hopes that things change. Otherwise, it feels like we’re watching another small business slowly head in the wrong direction. That said, the coffee is still good — so there’s that. I really hope they get back to what made them great… the bagels"

"Not good bagels, 3/10 overall. Won’t be back and don’t recommend. 1) They look burnt, they taste burnt, they are burnt. This is the biggest problem. 2) The bagels are too small; inside to crust ratio is too small. Maybe they aren’t using enough dough or aren’t letting the dough rise enough. Something is wrong there… 3) The inside is too much like a loaf of bread. It’s doesn’t have that chewy dense goodness. 4) They don’t do bakers dozens (weird for a bagel place but whatever I guess)."

"amazing bagels with very fresh and yummy selections to choose from! we all enjoyed our bagels and coffees immensely, though there weren’t much flavor options to choose from. That however did not bother me, as the taste of the coffee was really good and balanced in my personal opinion! I got a nova lox bagel with an iced brown sugar americano! my only issue was it was a bit spend for a coffee and bagel sadly. I will be back to visit, just not as often due to pricing. parking right now is not the best due to traffic but I parking was easy to find a block down!"

"The bagels here were awesome. Crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. Wish we could fit a dozen in our bag for the flight home."

"My Dad took me here when I first moved to Boise and I'm glad he did because it's quickly become one of my favorite spots in Boise! I love places that care about quality ingredients and food making and Good Times definitely checks that box. All their bagels are hand-rolled, boiled in honey water, and baked each morning in their wood-fired oven. And they certainly taste like it, too! Not only that but they have delicious coffee and matcha drinks. Their staff is always so friendly and helpful. Oh, and they also do wood-fired pizza night so definitely make sure to check that out because their pizzas are just as good as their bagels. And did I mention they serve wine at pizza night?"