"Really good pork roll & bagel and lox. Pork roll came on an everything bagel, not Kaiser roll, but we arrived closer to closing. Bagel and lox also good, not too much cream cheese or lox. A little pricey for sandwiches, but if you miss East Coast food, this'll hit the spot. They also serve soups & an array or hoagies."

"I got the jackhammer sandwich and it was melt in your mouth delicious! The little chocolate chip cookie they gave me with it… delectable. The staff was so so friendly!! Thanks for an amazing experience!"

"So good!!! The caprese sandwich was delightful and the balsamic sauce to dip it in is genius! Oh and that cookie!!! So good and a nice little great that comes with your sandwich! The shop is small and cozy and happy employees. We will hit this place up every time we are in Hailey!"

"I lived all my life in New England before moving to Hailey in 2019. I missed good seafood until today! Salt N’ Pepper has THE best clam chowder! Now I know where to go when I need my fix!"

"What a wonderful find! My wife and I just happened to stop by for a salad and sandwich right before closing. We were greeted as if we were the first customers of their day! The food was outstanding and they topped off our visit by giving us two homemade chocolate chip cookies for the road. I know where we’re having lunch the next time we’re in Hailey!"