"2/5 – Disappointing “lux” bagel experience I was in the mood for a luxe-style NYC bagel and decided to try Corey’s NYC Bagel. I ordered an everything bagel with plain cream cheese, lox, toppings, and a cup of coffee. The total came to around $28 with tip, which felt steep for what I got. The bagel itself was just average — definitely not living up to the “NYC bagel” reputation. The flavors were pretty bland, and one of the toppings was cucumber, which didn’t really fit the mix in my opinion. For the price, I expected a much more flavorful and balanced bagel. Overall, not a place I’d recommend, especially if you’re looking for that true NYC-style lox bagel experience."

"Im a New Yorker raised and born and i can tell you this def ain’t New York. This is so dry. & $10 just for this dry sandwich is insane. I dont mind payinf for quality but this is not. and the fact they don’t have rolls is crazy. NY would never. Never again."

"Mediocre (at best) sandwich and 2ounces of potato salad for over $18 after tax. Never again. Only redeeming quality might be the wider variety of menu they offer."

"We are from NJ where these are plentiful and high quality- this place met the mark! They even had Taylor Ham. Good bagel sandwiches made to order."

"Highly recommend! We got the salmon lox with the chive cream cheese and it was delicious!"