"This place is intimate and cozy with a small menu but everything on it looks amazing. I love how there are so many items to take to go. I've been here once but I'm excited to come back again soon!!"

"Nice little spot, great for lunch. Sandwiches are good and the baked goods are amazing. The blueberry cheesecake was delicious 😋"

"The French silk pie was great, but the raspberry pie was a very unpleasant texture, like way too much gelatin had been added to it. It was the consistency of firm tofu and didn’t taste good. The service was also quite unfriendly— we came in more than an hour before closing and were given our pies in plastic containers without being asked if we wanted to dine in, which we did. When I asked for plates, we were scolded before sitting down to bus them ourselves. We also never got real forks. No reason for the hostility. I won’t return."

"The slices of apple, cherry and strawberry- rhubarb and key lime pie are very generous and delicious. We also tried the meat lasagna and it was incredible, and very filling. It was worth the drive early evening for dinner and after dinner dessert with some tea! I highly recommend this place (just park a few blocks away and walk because non paid parking was a difficult)."

"So I've never been to the physical location but my friends had their pies at a party and ever since I can't stop ordering from First Slice. I'm obsessed with their sandwiches! They have the BEST combo. Sandwich + salad + chips & I always add a slice of pie too. My favorite pie is key lime I think but I've tried a hand full of theirs and they are all delicious. They have a really unique yummy balsamic pear pie. Their apple and cherry pies are phenomenal too. Looking forward to trying more things on the menu. Oh and my daughter loves their Mac and cheese. Thanks for feeding us! "