"Sooooo good! The shop is adorable, staff was super friendly, and the food was delicious. The breakfast sandwich was amazing- the biscuit looked like it might be dry, but it was very buttery and moist. The eggs and cheese were perfect too. Don’t even get me started on the pie. The chocolate cream pie was to die for. It’s so rich and smooth, everything you want out of a good chocolate pie. My mom was with us and had the stone fruit berry pie as well, which she said was delicious and sweet."

"What's not to love about this unique, local pie shop? I've been here a few times, and walked away happy every time. There are several size choices, and every flavour hits the spot. Decoration is lively, as is the staff. I make sure to leave time to visit every time I come to Chicago."

"Come for the breakfast items & Dollop Coffee and stay for their amazing pie! There is always a line. Some days it moves faster than others. Always fresh and locally sourced, I’venever had a bad bite here. I particularly like their muffins, fruit turnovers, & a biscuit with jam. My favorite pie is the “Fat Elvis.” There is ample seating both indoors and outdoors. The bustling cafe is a common meeting place for friend and families. Recommended."

"Wow! What a great place with so many delicious looking options. A friend suggested Hoosier Mama Pies to me and I am glad they did. I did not know what I wanted. A 'regular' graciously made some suggestions which were spot on. Thank-you to the front end clerk Rachel for being so friendly and kind to me. Her smile really lights things up. I ended up leaving with two 6 inch pies - chocolate chess and banana cream. Both are now just delicious memories."

"$3 for 2 hour street parking. We are lucky we always could find one last street parking across the street. Coconut cream pie ad Nuetella danish with Chai Baby. Chicken pot pie and chicken mole pie to go."