"Went on a Saturday morning. Place was packed and there was nowhere to sit. Staff trying to herd people through. Stated to set an understanding of the vibe. If you don't like pressure or a little stress ordering, go somewhere with table service. We had Paczkis and Croissants. The apricot and jalapeno+everything were stunningly good both as concepts and as end results. Well worth the experience of trying to find a warm place to eat them."

"A little over hyped. And it proved them right. The Monaco croissant sandwich was good. But the Cannoli, ooh full of sugar sans taste. Disappointed."

"Gave it a lower score only because of the prices. I really want to support local businesses, happened to be in Evanston for an appointment so I stopped in. (Been here before). The prices are very, very high. (Guess I should expect that when there are no prices shown on the baked goods in the cases). The espresso was not very good (to my palate). The bakery is delicious, but at these prices I may choose somewhere else in the future and be very careful with my selections."

"The cutest little spot in Evanston ❤️ We ordered our wedding cake through Bennison's, and they were wonderful to work with. I wanted a small, vintage cake for my husband and I to cut at our reception, and not only did the cake we picked up match my vision- it was also so, so delicious (we did a white cake with cherry jam). Thank you, Bennison's!"

"Stopped by Bennison's after seeing their very prominent and classic neon sign on the corner. The bakery really has an impressive selection of breads, cakes, cookies, and pastries available for purchase. I ended up getting a 6-pack of cheddar scallion biscuits (which were super delicious warmed up) and some Italian cookies. Everything was truly great and I will definitely be back again!"