
About Niyyah Coffee
Niyyah Coffee is McCordsville's welcoming neighborhood gem, where genuine hospitality and thoughtfully crafted drinks create an experience you won't find at a chain. With an impressive 4.9-star rating, community members consistently praise the inviting ambiance and exceptional service that make every visit feel like coming home. Stop by to discover why locals are excited to have this independent coffee shop as their new gathering place.
What People Are Saying
from Google"Very excited for this new coffee shop in McCordsville! Great ambiance and unique drink options! Tried The Bumble and my daughter had the Cozy Matcha — both were great. My daughter said it is the best matcha she’s ever had! Highly recommend!"
"Recently visited this Niyyah Coffee in McCordsville and was blown away by the level of service. The staff took the time to ask about my preferences and crafted a drink perfectly tailored to my taste. It wasn’t just a standard order, it felt personal and carefully made, with attention to detail in both flavor and presentation. Beyond the coffee, the friendly and attentive service made the entire experience warm and welcoming. This place truly goes above and beyond to make each guest feel valued."
"Finally was able to stop by the new coffee shop in McCordsville. I got a drink off of the secret menu and boy it’s so good! The cherry danish was AMAZING!!! Will definitely come back!"
"Always Fantastic over here! Stay away from the Biscoff Cake; Save some for me! 🤤 can’t go wrong with anything on this menu. Finally some actually good authentic coffee in the Fortville area. Beautiful place. Kind staff! I’ll try not to come here very day!"
"I was looking for a good place to work from with yummy drinks and have been curious about this place for about a month from passing it on my morning commute and friends' recommendations. Immediately upon entering, the atmosphere was calming, clean and serene - just what I was hoping for. The comfy chairs, soft music and beautiful natural lighting made it even better. Nate behind the counter was friendly and engaging, offering to clean my table before settling in. I'm a sucker for good customer service. I ordered the Zebra - a dark and white chocolate latte. It was out of this world delicious, and the menu variety is impressive. I can't wait to try their spin on the basics along with their unique lattes. Is it too soon to call me a regular?"