"Went on Sunday the 18th. Ordered bagels and cream cheese. Things moved quickly and I took my bagels home to enjoy with the family. I should have looked closer at the shill reviews.... Sus to say the least. This place should NOT try to sell itself as NY Bagels. They are FAR from it. I was really hoping for a quality bagel, but Manhattan Bagel & Coffee Co. missed the mark completely. The bagels were incredibly stale/bready and tough to chew. A good bagel should have a nice crust and a soft, chewy interior, but these felt like they had been sitting out for days. Honestly, they tasted and felt almost exactly like cheap, pre-packaged supermarket bagels. For a place with "Bagel" in the name, I expected much better. If you're looking for an authentic or fresh bagel in Boston, I would NOT recommend this spot. Save your money and go elsewhere."

"This place was pretty good. I ordered a breakfast sandwich (can't remember which one) and it was pretty good. The chive spread was a bit overwhelming but it was still good."

"Manhattan Bagels Shop is one of my favorite go-to spots for a quick and satisfying bite! They always serve bagels and coffee super quickly, and everything is fresh and hygienically prepared. I really appreciate how clean and well-organized the place always is. Every time I visit, I love trying their new varieties — each one tastes absolutely delicious and unique. Their bagels are soft, flavorful, and perfectly toasted, and the coffee is always rich and refreshing. The staff is friendly, attentive, and makes sure your order is just right. It’s a great place for breakfast, brunch, or even a light snack on the go. If you’re a bagel or coffee lover, I’d definitely recommend stopping by Manhattan Bagels — you’ll never be disappointed! ☕🥯"

"Great bagel, great coffee, and a fun atmosphere. I would highly recommend this place if you’re in Boston and need a bite!"

"Bagels are seriously delicious— amazing and fresh. They have a reading nook as well. I got everything with jalapeño cream cheese. Bagels are expensive but worth it. Huge portion."