"Incredibly cute and cozy setup inside of the old house. I loved all the little things for sale inside, and how it was combined with the seating area. The coffee was good—I got pumpkin in mine and I appreciated that it wasn’t too sweet, although it could’ve used a little more flavoring. The pumpkin muffin was also good, but was just a tiny bit overdone for my tastes. They only had takeout cups, and I think that some ceramic dine-in mugs would have made this even cozier!! Maybe something to add in the future. Overall, a great spot and definitely worth a visit!!"

"This place (Old Mill House) brings back good memories of my favorite coffee place in South Korea. It’s perfectly cozy, the decor is just like a home. The bathroom is sparkling. It must have taken a great deal of intentionality to put this place together. The space and displays inside resonated with my taste. My spouse immediately confessed to experiencing her dream coffee place! I just love this place and highly recommend for anyone that likes a right blend of seriousness and relaxation."

"Nice place. Great atmosphere. Even saw a couple on a first date, which it's really an idea place. My only gripe was the cocoa I bought wasn't very good, but I'm picky. I ended up only drinking less then half. I'd go again and try something different, I wouldn't let bad cocoa deter me lol."

"Cozy Spot with Great Vibes Stopped into Old Mill House Coffee for the first time today, and it did not disappoint. The food, the coffee, and the atmosphere were all on point. It’s a quaint, niche little place with a lot of charm — you can tell it has its own character in the best way. Definitely planning to come back soon. Two thumbs up."

"Such a cute coffee shop! They have a ton of items made locally for sale inside and the staff was very friendly. I got the cold brew which was great, it was not bitter at all. I would definitely go back here!"