"Horrible quality! I ordered a roast beef, onion and Mayo sandwich which had so much fat and grizzle it was inedible. For $12, this is a crime. If they had eyes in their head, they could see what they were making and yet they think this is ok to serve to their customers. On my first bite I could tell something was off. Look at these pics, this is just the grizzle and fat part that I took out! Would NEVER go back or recommend!"

"Great first experience at this new local deli! I got "The Phillip" (since I'm a big fan of broccoli rabe on a sandwich) and it was great! Excellent bread which is very important. As a market, Scafidi Bros has some nice offerings including meals to go as well as things like pasta and olive oil (the Monini brand I tried is really working for me) and fancy Italian sodas (the blood orange one is really good)."

"Scafidis is a great family owned deli! The food is just as incredible as the people making it. What a fantastic recommendation by Lisa, and I cant wait to go back to try the cannolis!!"

"I decided to host my wife's 50th birthday party at home this year and needed a caterer that had traditional Italian dishes and sandwiches. Scafidi Bros. did not disappoint. We had about 50 people over and the food was a big hit. The owner Teddy showed up right on time, helped set up the trays, and gave detailed instructions on how to keep the dishes hot and serve them throughout the night. He even loaned us a big wicker basket to serve the bread when I realized we didn't have anything to put it in. They couldn't be nicer and more professional. I would highly recommend Scafidi Bros. for your catering needs. I've also grabbed sandwiches from the shop a couple times and love every one I've tried."

"The chicken parm sub at Scafidi Bros is unreal. Easily one of the best I’ve had anywhere. Perfect crispy chicken, the sauce is fire, and the whole thing just hits different. If you haven’t tried it yet you’re missing out."