"While visiting Annapolis, we randomly stopped by an ice cream shop. The variety of flavors was impressive, the texture of the ice cream was very good, and the sugar level was perfect for my taste. I really liked it. There were true ice-cream lovers in our group, and even their expert opinions were positive. If you’re in the area, stop by and give it a try."

"This is seriously the best ice cream in Annapolis! The flavors are rich, creamy, and full of real, fresh taste; nothing artificial. You can tell everything is homemade. We came with our kids and everyone found something they loved. It’s a perfect stop for families, especially on a warm day downtown. The staff was kind and patient! If you’re visiting Annapolis or live nearby, don’t miss this place. It’s a local gem!"

"Cute place, good variety of flavors. I got the cookie monster and coffee chocolate chip. Cookie monster taste like cookies and cream but blue. Coffee chocolate chip had a great coffee flavor. My mom got strawberry and vanilla. All four flavors were great!"

"Very delicious, creamy ice cream! We got the carrot cake and peanut butter oreo flavors. My boyfriend thinks it is the best ice cream in Annapolis!"

"I was hoping for a pure coconut flavor, but the chocolate chips overwhelmed it, making the coconut barely noticeable. While the shop claims the ice cream is homemade, the waffle cone didn’t taste like it. If both shops claim homemade ice cream, I’d much rather go with Old Mill Creamery in Annapolis. Their flavors are more balanced and true to description. This one just didn’t deliver."