"Delicious bakery items, sandwiches and coffee & tea selections. Friendly staff, plenty of seating, indoors and out. Outdoor seating is beautifully decorated. Seasonal coffee was delicious. Pumpkin scone perfect. Lots of unique local decor and food items for sale. Fun book nook."

"We came here because of the reviews. However it was a little disappointing. Ambiance: quaint, cute little place with cute courtyard seating. Counter staff and waiting satff: very nice and pleasant greeting customers. Food: mehh, we ordered a Turkey and Cheddar sandwich, a caprese on sour dough bread instead of Ciabatta, a pumpkin spice latte and a harvest Chai (asked for bith to be extra extra hot). My Harvest Chai was really good except it was not extra hot. The pumpkin spice latte was bland, could not taste the pumpkin spice at all. Turkey sandwich was alright, nothing special too much mustard. Caprese sandwich: I have had better ones at different places - the Mozzarella was too thick, the pesto was salty and wasn't spread out, just a glob in the middle and same with the balsamic dressing, which makes everything saltier and sour. Other places use aged balsamic which has a little tangy and sweetness to it to balance out the pesto. I also notice there were not much choices in the cases perhaps because its 2 o'clock in the afternoon. Totally understandable. Over-all, nit up to par with all the lavishing reviews. But we definitely will come back for a second chance. Maybe, it's because it's late in the afternoon when we got there."

"Old Mill Cafe is a fantastic place to get coffee, sandwiches, pastries and more! The food here is great! The staff is friendly and there are so many different pastries to choose from, you will have to come back for a second visit. The turkey and ham sandwiches were delicious, and the croissants are baked to perfection! The lemon pop tart left a little to be desired, as the filling was somewhat gelatinous and artificial tasting/looking, but all in all this was a fantastic café, and will be back again soon!"

"What a cute and quaint cafe! I had the toasted croissant with ham and cheese, and my wife had the spinach and feta cheese quiche. Both were very good. We also had the cappuccino coffee. Also very good. We also brought some of their pastries home with us. There are about eight tables that seat about three people each. As well as a counter with stools. There are also tables and chairs in front of the cafe for when the weather is nice. It reminds me of the shops and cafes in the Village on the West side of downtown Manhattan when I lived in NYC. It's definitely a very popular destination with the locals. Ellicott City is a quaint town right outside Baltimore, Md. with dozens of small shops. I highly recommend a visit to this cafe and city."

"Asked for a blueberry bagel and berry cream cheese for my daughter, they gave me one with regular cream cheese and said they dont have berry and must've heard me wrong. I asked to exchange it for one with just butter because she wouldn't eat it and they said no, I'd have to buy a different one. It was the guy with big earrings and a beanie hat on. Won't be coming back"