"The Bagelry is one of the best bagel shops in the area but it's definitely overpriced. I love their selection of bagged older bagels for a decent price, but they charge extra to toast the bagels. They have a huge selection of cream cheese flavors and are generous in their portions and they have a pretty solid lunch menu. The pizza bagel was a definite miss because it was flavorless and bland but the turkey jerky is good with lots of turkey. There isn't a place to sit and relax, but there are tall standing tables. It's best to order to go. The cost makes it tough to have a weekly breakfast bagel run but I haven't found another shop in the near vicinity with tastier bagels. Give it a try if you love bagels."

"While I'm still a fan of another area well known bagel shop (CYM), The Bagelry has definitely grown on me. Going on the bagels alone, they beat CYM in my opinion. They're perfectly chewy and have that "bite" and crunch when toasted. The Bagelry's cream cheese spreads are good, but I wish they had a fresh herb variety. I haven't had the chance to try any sandwich but going on their bagel quality alone, The Bagelry is tops in the area. It's worth a try, especially if you habitually go to another local bagel shop. It took a handful of visits for me to make my determination that they are now my favorite bagel."

"Servers are friendly. The bagels are fresh. I appreciate the various flavor options. We also ordered the French toast but its nothing close to it. The bread was dry with not a bit of moisture or egg. And the egg was the worst. It doesn't look natural to me. I wouldn't return here."

"Update 2023: still the best place to get a bagel in the silver spring area. Best to get here early on Sunday or the line could be a bit long. The selection is quite generous on the bagels and sandwiches and the prices are reasonable. Big selection of fresh tasty bagels. The Nova on the run is a little pricy but very good. I must try if you like lox. The chocolate chip bagels and the cinnamon bagels are the kids favorite."

"Delicious fresh-baked bagels! I bought a dozen of different sorts (mostly savory and a few sweet) along with some light cream cheese. I paid to have the bagels sliced since I was going straight to a brunch."