"Fantastic gelato! We stopped here after a Mariners game and it was the perfect end to our night. Super busy and rightfully so. Huge variety of flavors, they have something for everyone. They even had a brown butter lobster flavor 🦞! Every flavor we tried was excellent. Make sure to visit, you will not be disappointed!"

"Excellent gelato! They have a huge variety of flavours - we had the homemade chocolate which creamy and dark, special hazelnut was amazing, and espresso chip, which was delicious. And the Afagato is pretty tasty too! You can add as many flavours as you want in a cup. They have treat, small, medium and large sizes. It has outdoor seating as well for rare sunny days!"

"Update: We are doing a tasting of Portland gelatos. I like mixing the sweet and sour flavors for a burst of flavors. Fiasco is the winner, providing great chocolate for sweet and strawberry sorbetto for sour. --- original review below Nice selection of gelato and sorbetto. I thought the strawberry sonetto was very flavorful. The smallest size is called Treat and costs $4.35. It is a nice size for a treat, a perfect name. The bathroom is closed with a key pad, big step down to enter. Watch your step going in and out. Should have been a ramp for customer safety."

"This place had amazing gelato and really great service despite it being busy! The gentleman that served us was so kind. We tried so many flavors and he was really patient. We loved our experience here. I tried the Maine blueberry 🫐 and the Maine blueberry 🫐 tart flavor. Both were exceptional and I just ended up getting like every flavor I tried. I got the chocolate and the hazelnut which were also spectacular. My sister got the mango sorbetto and stratiatella and she really enjoyed both. There is not shortage of flavors here and the service was really nice. 😊 Highly recommend."

"Absolutely LOVED Gelato Fiasco. I specifically love this one in downtown Old Port because of the cute little shops near it. You can eat your yummy gelato while walking and going to the little stores and stuff. It's a good date/hang-out idea. There are a lot of flavors offered by Gelato Fiasco and every time I've gone, the workers are always so nice, despite the busy environment they work in. There's always people in the store, but they move fast and offer good service. The seating inside is small, but there's also a ton of outdoor sitting area by the store and just around the corner (literally everywhere)."