"I'm torn because I've had some truly great experiences at Strange Donuts, but other times I've felt so disappointed. But every one of these great experiences has come from getting their weekly "Stranger" donut that they post on Instagram, where they post a new donut that's especially strange, especially huge, and is available that weekend across all of their locations. That's where I tried by far the best two donuts I've had from Strange Donuts: - blueberry lemon fruit loop donut - cosmic brownie donut with chocolate buttercream frosting and chocolate custard filling. But outside of these donuts that get posted on Instagram, I've generally been disappointed by what I got from Strange Donuts. Their fillings and frostings are well-executed, but the actual donut falls short at least on their yeast-based donuts. Be mindful of stranger danger when it comes to Strange Donuts' regular donuts. But if you see a donut that aligns with your taste preferences that's posted as their "Stranger" donut on Instagram for the week, unleash your inner sumo wrestler and grab one of these mega-sized masterpieces. You won't be disappointed. blueberry lemon fruit loop donut > cosmic brownie donut with chocolate buttercream frosting and chocolate custard filling > raspberry cheesecake donut > gooey butter cake donut"

"First time trying out Strange Donuts. I had an old gift card, but unfortunately it didn't have any value left on it (could be my fault for not hsing it). I got 4 donuts to share with my family. I cut them so we could all try a piece, but unfortunately they just didn't taste spectacular. They almost tasted a bit stale even though I picked them up at 7am. I'll stick with my tried and true basic glazed at another place. Not up to the hype."

"This used to be awesome. The donuts were packed with crazy designs, inventive flavors and fresh. There was almost always a line out the door with a hip vibe that was reflecive of Maplewood. I really miss it. Something changed around the time they opened the 2nd location & each experience since has been.. bland at best. So, here's my review of today's experience & likely my last: We bought a dozen with a mix of Sparkle Pony, long John's, Chocolate Strawberry, KoolAid Jelly, Gooey Butter & Mocha Frappe Pie. Donuts are pretty, but taste stale & cold, like they were made the night before or somewhere else. The icings are all dry and crunchy. The Jelly filings had a nice pop that was redeemable. The vibe & personality is gone. No hip music or cool merch. The service hands you donuts without excitement. I'm super PRO Maplewood. It hurts to say, but unless something changes, I don't recommend Strange Donuts. I paid $35 & could've gotten 100% better, fresh donuts at Schnucks for $12. Next time, I'll see who else wants business. However, maybe things are fresh in the afternoon."

"I tried Strange Donuts for the first time and I’m only giving it 3.5 stars because the donut was on the “thick” side. It felt like I was eating a lot of dough/bread and I like my donuts to be on the lighter/fluffier/airy side. I don’t like to feel like it’s taking me a while to eat a donut. The donut itself is good it’s just a lot of dough for me."

"The donuts were excellent! I'd rank them up there with the best! My favorite is the Peanut Butter Banana. Those are my favorite flavors, and no one else makes a donut quite like it."