About Pizzashop
Pizzashop brings authentic New York flavor to Oxford, where genuine hospitality meets quality craft. From the moment you walk through the door, you're greeted with attentive service that makes every visit feel personal—something you won't find at a chain. With their thoughtfully curated menu and standout pizzas like the Butcher Shop, this independent spot has earned its 4.5-star reputation by prioritizing real connection alongside exceptional food.
What People Are Saying
from Google"They brought their New York prices with them. Limited menu, the Butcher Shop pizza was good, though the crust was a bit tough and burned in the edges. The wings were baked not fried. Bathroom was disgusting."
"Great pizza! Excellent attentive service. Before the door could shut after entering we were greeted and made to feel welcome. The pizza was made with Fresh, Quality ingredients that were evident in the taste of the pizza. Hand tossed crust was very good. Will go back again when in town!"
"For a little NY Pizza Shop, they have a great menu, and wonderful pizza! Slice special with drink is a great deal!"
"10/10 all around. Great good, great service, cute building and great prices. Me and my husband got the lunch deal, 2 slices of pizza and a drink for $8 and that’s hard to beat. Some of the best pizza we’ve had in Oxford. We will definitely be back"
"The pizza was absolutely delicious. Staff and service was excellent. Will be going back again."
