"1st time here. Had the jalapeño Popper bagel and a dark roast. The bagel was so fresh, with the. Cream cheese and bacon OMG so good ! Lot's of goodies to choose from here. Adding them to my favorite's."

"Visited on a Saturday morning. Line was at the door when we walked in, but the wait wasnt long at all! The staff was friendly and super quick. We ordered a brownie, raspberry bismark, and an eclair. All three were wonderful and the prices were great! Highly recommended and will be back again soon."

"We love Potters House Bakery! We have been ordering cakes from them for the past two years for all our events. Their cakes are taste fantastic and always look wonderful! We get compliments on the cakes whenever we serve them and are sure to let them know they’re from potters. We love their bakery items too! (A pic of our most recent cake, a hobbit themed birthday cake)"

"Excellent Aerocano and Swiss roll! I'm so glad I tried this place. The Aerocano doesn't need milk or cream! Such a smooth and tasty espresso treat 😋 The Swiss roll was amazingly delicious and perfectly made. 👌🤤"

"I love Potters! My coworkers and I discovered this place when we used to frequent Rochester for work, and although we rarely go in to town for work anymore we make the drive just for their sandwiches and treats. The staff is awesome, the food is delicious, and the prices are super reasonable. Truly a gem with so much to offer. Worth the stop in!"