"I’ve been coming here for over 5 years, Since I moved into town, for dry sausage, stuffed peppers, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, sauce, fried eggplant, and the occasional sandwich. I live next to it and I grew up in Little Italy in Cleveland Ohio. My family are all Italian cooks, restaurant owner, and wannabe chefs, and going to the Italian deli as a kid is a core memory for me. This place is the best deli in town. They are super friendly and everything is amazing - but the real prize is their fried eggplant. Its the best I’ve ever had and honestly, I couldn’t even do it better myself, so I don’t try. Do yourself a favor and get a sandwich with it, and then some on the side too. 🤌🏻🤌🏻🤌🏻 Sandwich in photo is the Di Matteao"

"the best deli around. the staff is incredible nice, the owner seems very nice and Sue went out of her way to make my day ❤️ Been coming here every Monday for months and it’s become a tradition. Veggie sandwich with pesto is my favorite☺️"

"Finally made it here and tried the Belgiovine Special Italian sandwich. Absolutely delicious!! Got a few other things here as well; everything was great! Great service, portions size, and food! Can’t wait to try other things. Cat (Butter) for scale."

"Disappointing Italian Sub Experience I recently tried the Italian sub and I have to say, it was a letdown. For $19, I expected a flavorful sandwich packed with quality ingredients, but what I got was bland and unexciting. The bread was okay, but it didn’t really stand out. The meat was sparse and lacked any real flavor – it felt more like an afterthought than the main attraction. I was hoping for a robust mix of Italian meats, but it was practically nonexistent. The lack of seasoning was shocking; even a sprinkle of salt or some herbs would have made a world of difference. Overall, I left feeling unsatisfied and wishing I had spent my money elsewhere. If you’re looking for an authentic Italian sub that delivers on taste and value, keep looking. This one is not worth the price tag."

"Pizza lunch Party of 4 Thin crust pizza tasty! Garlic knots were amazing! Walking distance to Montclair Art Museum!"