"Awesome Gelato and Outstanding Service every time! I had the Affogato paired with the Hazelnut Gelato, and it was absolutely amazing. The Sorbetto Was Delicious!! The Cookies are also Good and make a great treat on the side. Definitely a spot I’d recommend to anyone looking to satisfy their sweet tooth!"

"Perfect little ice cream spot if you’re walking through Montclair or on your way back from having dinner. Gelato is made on site which is kind of relaxing to watch if you have the time. Scoop sizes are not overwhelming at all which was nice since it’s a soft ice cream to begin with. You don’t feel forced to have to start eating it as soon as you get it in fear of it melting. Staff is super friendly too."

"Absolutely best ice cream I’ve had in the USA. Rich, creamy and simply just delicious. I’ve got the medium cup with one scoop of chocolate sorbet and a scoop of the hazelnut gelato. The combination is just divine tasting like nutella. My boyfriend got the espresso stracciatella which was also very good. We will absolutely come again and I believe you can buy a pint of it also, might do that and have a treat at home 👀 Please go and try."

"This place is a 10 and the gelato/ice cream is a solid 10. The flavors are really specialty. The coffee with biscotti was heavenly.. the ice creams are soft and fresh.. I loved that it’s v v clean and charming. They have lots of Italian cookies and if you are a amaretti cookies fan like you can get some here. Also serving size is very diet friendly..I recommend Nutella, mascarpone.. will be a regular here"

"Benvenuti has grest Gelato and the most reasonably priced warm cookies on Church Street ! Cozy tables in a intimate atmosphere to enjoy your sugar fix after dinner. I endulged in the stores cookie and it's quite the late night bargain in Montclair. The chocolate chip cookie gives the smores cookie a run for the money!!! And who doesn't love Gelato??? Highly recommend Benvenuti Montclair !!!"