"This place was absolutely amazing! We got a sub on a pickle and a regular sub as well to try them both out. The regular sub was amazing, cold cuts sliced nice and thin and very fresh. Bread was soft and perfect. Now on to the pickle sub. I was worried it would be overwhelming or feel like it was lacking something, hence why we also got a normal sub as well. However, it was amazing. The pickles were nice and crunchy and fresh, and actually tasted really good with the cold cuts. A good keto option if you don’t eat carbs, and the fun and excitement of a pickle sub definitely doesn’t make you feel like you’re missing out on the bread! The service was super quick and the atmosphere was nice."

"The best sub shop at the Jersey Shore!! My Aunt Barbara and Uncle David loved this spot as kids so this place holds a special place in my heart. The subs are always fresh!! My favorite is the Pickle Sub!!"

"How on earth have I not reviewed Elsie’s subs before?! Even though I live in Florida now, Elsie’s is a must visit for me any time I’m in NJ. Their Turkey cranberry is just absolutely perfect. Bread is perfect, ratio of meat to toppings is perfect - even the hole in the wall look of the restaurant is perfect! They also have a great selection of chips and drinks to go with their wide menu of subs. It is a cash only place and you generally will have to park in the large paid city parking lot behind the store. But seriously - if you are anywhere near Red Bank, go out of your way to stop in at Elsie’s."

"Elsie’s Sub Shop in Red Bank N.J Best Subs Anywhere in The Country !!! Another Daddy -Daughter Lunch with Jilly.This Little Tucked away Sub Shops Makes The Best Biggest Tastiest Sandwiches on Earth !! Established in 1959 2 years After I Was Born. This is My Go To Place for Sub Sandwiches I usually Get The Whole Italian(All Their Sandwiches are Fantastic) Salt-Pepper Oregano Olive Oil & Vinegar and I’m in Heaven !!! I say there is No Way I Can Finish the Whole Thing…But I Always Do 😂😂😂 Support your Local Mom & Pop Restaurants Cause if you Don’t your Favorites Could Disappear !!! Cash Only ATM inside Large Paid Parking in Rear or Park on Monmouth Street All Paid Parking. Also Has a Large Variety of Chips and Snacks … The Owner is Very Knowledgeable about Food Costs But She’s been keeping Her Prices Affordable and Not Raising Her Prices SUPPORT THE ESTABLISHMENT it’s an Historical Site in Downtown Red Bank"

"My seven year old loved the chicken sandwich I had cheese steak, no bread This seems very old school like they e been here a very long time Clean friendly people, lots of choices Fresh Adorable classic sub shop Don’t miss if you want sandwiches in red bank I suggest to loose weight going low or no carb. They were happy to cater to me We sat at the window to look at Monmouth St. We will be back"