"I had an amazing time at OddFellows Ice Cream Co.! The ice cream was delicious, and the service was outstanding. In fact best Vanilla Bean / Coffee ice cream I have had - very smooth and not too sweet. As someone with lactose intolerance, I loved that they offered Lactaid pills right before I ate my scoop—it made a huge difference and let me enjoy every bite. The staff was friendly and the atmosphere was warm. I’m from Florida, and we don’t have OddFellows in my city, but I really think we should! With so many great reviews from people like Stephen Colbert and David Chang, it’s clear this is a must-visit spot. The location in Dumbo is clean and festive - If you’re nearby, you have to stop by and try it for yourself!"

"OddFellows Ice Cream Co. is such a fun and creative spot! The flavors are unique, playful, and really stand out compared to typical ice cream shops. Everything tasted super fresh and creamy, and you can tell they put thought into balancing flavors. The shop itself has a cool, welcoming vibe, making it a great place to hang out with friends or just treat yourself. Definitely one of the nicest ice cream places I’ve tried—worth stopping by if you’re in the area!"

"Came here a while ago during their limited time breast milk ice cream popup. Surprisingly one of the best ice cream I’ve had in the city - super simple vanilla honey caramel tones and not too sweet, it’s a shame that flavor isn’t available anymore. Haven’t been back here since but big fan of the unique flavors and dedication to the marketing moment with the boxes and art on the walls."

"YUM! After walking the Brooklyn Bridge... ice cream sounded like a great idea. Originally, we were going to go to a different ice cream spot but the vibes on this one caught my eye. So glad we stopped here. The ice cream was delicious. I got raspberry rocky road & coffee crunch in a cup. Then my daughter got strawberry match and black sesame seed cookies & cream in a cone. They also had vegan options."

"Excellent desserts destination in the neighborhood of DUMBO. They offer both dairy and vegan options with wonderfully unique flavors. The interior of the shop is a little quirky, but it does have some seats, and there is a restroom available. During our last visit, there was only one young man running the shop and serving the customers. The line went out the door and over to the next business. The customers were very cordial, and the employee took orders and ran operations like a boss."