"Love the pie! We tried the brown butter pecan honey pie and it’s the best! The hot latte is great too. Will definitely come back again!"

"Love their pies, perfect crust, however… Tonight, my friends and I felt for a treat and decided to order in from Petee’s. Tell me why I opened the bag (didn’t even open the container) and 1/3 of my slice is missing 😒Why would you sell a pie slice that’s not whole?! I obviously can’t eat the rest because what if I just got someone’s half eaten pie…? This is weird man, just don’t sell the slice."

"Wandered in here and had the Salty Chocolate Chess pie and it was insanely good! Like if my stomach had no limit I would eat the whole pie! Super decadent and creamy!!! I paired it with the maple whipped cream (that they also make in house)!! Also appreciate their effort to have high quality and ethical ingredients!! The staff is also super sweet and welcoming! Also great at giving recommendations!!"

"Petee's is the bar...and its extremely high. Best pie in NYC. Took a poll at my workplace near the cafe; as the neighborhood changes lunch options shift, it was unanimous, we all deeply miss Petee's savory pie options. Their chicken pot pie was like going home to visit Grandma. Outstanding. Love you guys! Thank you for all these wonderful years of perfect pie."

"I've only ever had blueberry crumb and apple crumb but I've had it many, many times. Absolutely incredible. I buy them as gifts too. Just delicious and incredible. The staff are wonderful. They're open late. Oh and I had a latte once. Their coffee is great too! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED."