About Kismet Coffee Company
Kismet Coffee Company is where the community gathers for genuine connection over exceptional coffee. Our carefully crafted beverages—from silky iced coffee to perfectly spiced chai lattes—reflect the care we pour into every cup. Whether you're starting your Sunday morning or unwinding with us, you'll find the kind of authentic warmth and quality that only an independent café can offer. We're more than coffee; we're your neighborhood gathering place.
What People Are Saying
from Google & Yelp"One of the best iced coffee I've had, hands down. Fresh and delicious. Great vibes. Tell em Barsnobs sent ya!"
"I couldn’t think of a better way to spend my Sunday morning other than having the best Chai Latte on Fire Island …bonus the best chocolate chip cookie I ever had. I have had Kismet Companies cappuccino and espresso…both I would highly recommend. If you’re on Fire Island stop in..you won’t be disappointed ❤️☕️"
"If you have not tried Kismet Coffee Co you are denying yourself great coffee, food, and amazing service !! Everything is customized to your request, fresh, and so good. I can not say enough great things about Kismet Coffee Co. !!"
"If you are on Fire Island in the town of Kismet stopping by Kismet Coffee Co. is a must. They have a great selection of coffee and tea that you can order hot or cold. My favorite is the latte which is delicious, and I’ve always had a great customer experience there because the staff is friendly and welcoming. I am a Fire Island person and it is one of my most favorite places. I highly recommend it."
"Relaxed fire island atmosphere offering a small food menu and a wonderful coffee menu."
"What even is the point of this place? We thought we'd come here for a small bite and a mimosa but they were out of most stuff and didn't serve alcohol til..."