"Pisellino is one of those New York classics that never disappoints. I stopped by for aperitivos and it was the perfect pause in the middle of the city. The atmosphere feels effortlessly European — intimate, timeless, and full of character. Soft lighting, beautiful details, and that unmistakable West Village energy. The aperitivos were perfectly executed, ideal for a late afternoon or early evening moment. It’s the kind of place where you sit down “just for one” and end up staying longer than planned. Lively without being loud, polished without feeling stiff. A true NYC staple and an unmissable spot if you appreciate good drinks, great ambiance, and places with soul."

"The atmosphere is so beautiful and cozy. The waiter explained us everything and every cocktail! The cocktails were so delicious and well made! We drink four of them with olives which were perfect, and a plate with cheese and salami. We totally going back before leaving New York City!"

"I come here every morning for my coffee, orange juice, and San Pellegrino. Sitting on Grove Street, watching the world go by, is genuinely one of the highlights of my day. The coffee is always brewed properly, at the right temperature. The orange juice is freshly squeezed to order—sometimes with that beautiful blood-orange hue, and it’s consistently excellent. But the real reason I keep coming back is the staff. They’re kind, attentive, and always happy to say good morning, have a brief chat, and let you get on with your day. Shout-out to Christian, Nick, and the entire team, you make an already great space even better with your warmth and energy. It gets busy later in the day and at night, which says everything you need to know. My time is the morning, and I’ll let the evening crowd speak for itself. The staff do an incredible job, and I come back as much for their company as for the coffee."

"We initially loved this place — great atmosphere, good coffee and tea, and tasty sandwiches. We were visiting West Village from another city and truly enjoyed the vibe. The experience changed when we casually started filming ourselves as bloggers. We were approached several times and told that filming was not allowed and that we would need to schedule a photoshoot via email. This was not a professional photoshoot — just simple content creation, capturing ourselves and the atmosphere. It was disappointing, especially since filming in public spaces is common in the U.S., and we genuinely wanted to share and recommend this place. A great atmosphere at first, but the approach toward content creators left a negative impression."

"Deliciously perfect hot chocolate. Despite how busy it was, the server was incredibly friendly and seated us quickly. He was especially thoughtful knowing we had a child and made sure we were comfortable. The donut was the best I’ve ever had—exceptionally soft and not overly sweet."