
What People Are Saying
from Google"This a small hotel lobby bar tucked away in the Indigo Hotel Lobby. But for those fortunate enough to wander upon it, you're in for a great surprise! This is an institution that clearly values their guests, customers and patrons. Whether it's hotel guests simply staying the night, frequently traveling business people or locals seeking a high class establishment, Buttonwood doesn't disappoint. Whether you're served by the owner Willie or by the bartender Josh, you'll find the cocktail experience second to none. Dazzlingly fresh ingredients line the bar, cucumbers, strawberries, mint, fresh fruits from a basket used to sell to hotel guests. Bartenders reach into their stock to chop, muddle and shake premium cocktails to perfection. Beautiful crystal glasswear, stunning granite bartop, and fantastic funky music only add to the allure and ambiance of this top class establishment. I tried the food and it's was FANTASTIC. Ordering the burger I was pleasantly surprised to find it is a thick, juicy, cheesy, crispy experience, cooked perfectly to order. A far cry from a smash burger or fastfood style puny patty on a frozen bun, this is a steakhouse style burger that imo far out classes anything in the area. My tablemates had the salmon and pan seared chicken with mushroom sauce that both looked absolutely amazing. The Salmon in particular appeared glistening and butter soft. All dishes were an ample portion without overdoing it. In all what I would say about is, this an intimate, upscale, classy, dimlit establishment with phenomenal cocktails, great food and funky fantastic music. It's a real gem..."
"Fine but nothing special. You are basically having breakfast in a windowless bar with a bartender serving you. Both empty and kind of noisy. Forced 18% gratuity. Not sure how this place managed to get such a high star rating."
"I was really disappointed with my experience at Buttonwood Café. When I asked about toast, the server told me it would be $1. However, when the check came, I was charged $4 instead. On top of that, the server added a tip to the bill without asking or informing me. I always leave a tip when the service is good, but I don’t appreciate it being added automatically without my consent. It felt misleading and unprofessional."
"They make a new homemade soup every night. The breakfast is fantastic. The drinks are great. The service is friendly and professional, especially the owner who is very engaging."
"Amazing mocktails!! The bartender makes whatever you feel like!!!"
Hours
Nearby Coffee Shops in New York